Wikipedia talk:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 March 21
Appearance
Places of worship
Full list of categories
OPTION A
Use "religious buildings"
- Category:Places of worship by city to Category:Religious buildings by city
- Category:Places of worship by continent to Category:Religious buildings by continent
- Category:Places of worship by country to Category:Religious buildings by country
- Category:Places of worship by country and city to Category:Religious buildings by country and city
- Category:Places of worship by heritage register to Category:Religious buildings by heritage register
- Category:Places of worship by religious body to Category:Religious buildings by religious body
OPTION B
Use "religious buildings and structures".Note that this option involves renaming all the existing "religious buildings" categories to "religious buildings and structures"
- Category:Places of worship to Category:Religious buildings and structures
- Category:Places of worship by city to Category:Religious buildings and structures by city
- Category:Places of worship by continent to Category:Religious buildings and structures by continent
- Category:Places of worship by country to Category:Religious buildings and structures by country
- Category:Places of worship by country and city to Category:Religious buildings and structures by country and city
- Category:Places of worship by heritage register to Category:Religious buildings and structures by heritage register
- Category:Places of worship by religious body to Category:Religious buildings and structures by religious body
Religious buildings
- Category:Religious buildings to Category:Religious buildings and structures
- Category:Religious buildings by century to Category:Religious buildings and structures by century
- Category:Religious buildings by continent to Category:Religious buildings and structures by continent
- Category:Religious buildings by country to Category:Religious buildings and structures by country
- Category:Religious buildings by millennium to Category:Religious buildings and structures by millennium
- Category:Religious buildings by year to Category:Religious buildings and structures by year
Consider omitting "and structures"
- Category:Disasters in places of worship to Category:Disasters in religious buildings and structures
- Category:Massacres in places of worship to Category:Massacres in religious buildings and structures
- Category:Films set in religious buildings to Category:Films set in religious buildings and structures
- Category:Conversion of non-Christian places of worship into churches to Category:Conversion of non-Christian religious buildings and structures into churches
- Category:Places of worship converted into mosques to Category:Religious buildings and structures converted into mosques
- Category:Places of worship converted to a different religion to Category:Religious buildings and structures converted to a different religion
- Category:Religious buildings with domes to Category:Religious buildings and structures with domes
The above categories only apply to buildings, not structures. Is the longer name "and structures" necessary/appropriate? – Fayenatic London 07:25, 20 April 2019 (UTC)
- Sorry for a slow reply, @Fayenatic london. This may now be moot ... but if not, then it seems to me to be a choice between consistency and avoiding redundancy. I am not sure which to prioritise. Any thoughts? --BrownHairedGirl (talk) • (contribs) 20:27, 22 April 2019 (UTC)
- Right, that's exactly the choice. If you hadn't replied shortly, I was going to go ahead with the longer name anyway.
- The category "…converted into mosques" includes Cave of the Patriarchs and Temple Mount, which indicate that the longer name will be appropriate in that case at least.
- If I leave some with shorter but inconsistent names, not backed by consensus, then they would probably get speedily renamed under C2C anyway. So we might as well go straight to that. – Fayenatic London 21:08, 22 April 2019 (UTC)
- Sounds like a wise solution, @Fayenatic. Thanks again. --BrownHairedGirl (talk) • (contribs) 04:33, 23 April 2019 (UTC)
Duplicate pages on Wikidata
Cases where both exist on Wikidata, to be considered for merging:
- Not done, too much work as both categories exist for multiple countries
- Done
- Category:Places of worship in Africa to Category:Religious buildings and structures in Africa
- Category:Places of worship in Asia to Category:Religious buildings and structures in Asia
- Category:Places of worship in Europe to Category:Religious buildings and structures in Europe
- Category:Places of worship in North America to Category:Religious buildings and structures in North America
- Category:Places of worship in Oceania to Category:Religious buildings and structures in Oceania
Wikidata was not properly updated
Many of the "Places of worship" categories are still linked to Wikidata, even though the pages were moved and redirected to "religious buildings and structures".