User:Sgt. R.K. Blue/XfD

Source: Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.


This page, to be updated approximately every four months, contains tables indexing my participation in various XfD discussions on Wikipedia. It may be of value in my assessment should I ever decide to go before a request for adminship someday.

Last updated June 19, 2012.

Articles for deletion

# Article for deletion Date participated (UTC) My recommendation Consensus decision Notes
1 Jeff Bennett 2010-03-03 Keep Keep My first XfD discussion
2 Oz Griebel 2010-04-23 Delete Keep
3 Polish Historical Society (United States) 2010-04-26 Delete Delete
4 2008 New Britain Rock Cats season 2010-05-03 Delete Delete I was the nominator
5 Upstate Connecticut 2010-05-31 Delete Delete
6 Jericho Scott 2010-06-15 Comment (neutral) Delete
7 Lou Rell 2010-08-12 Comment (no objection; raised question) Redirect
8 Fanpop.com 2011-01-20 Keep and improve Delete Made additional comment on 2011-01-23
9 List of sister cities in New England 2011-03-09 Keep Keep
10 2002 Mitt Romney residency issue 2011-04-06 Delete Delete
11 Jedediah Chapman 2011-04-14 Delete Delete
12 Caroline Lazar 2011-04-19 Delete Delete
13 Danny A. Jacobs 2011-05-15 Delete Delete
14 Josip on deck 2011-05-23 Delete Delete
15 Kristine Larsen 2011-05-29 Delete Delete
16 Springdale Little League 2011-06-16 Delete Delete
17 List of fan fiction terms 2011-06-19 Move to Wiktionary, leave soft redirect Move to Wiktionary This was the article's third AfD
18 Best & Co. (retailer founded 1997 2011-06-22 Merge Merge without redirect
19 Norway 2011 Attack Victims 2011-07-31 Delete Delete
20 Rachel Frank (meteorologist) 2011-08-19 Delete Delete
21 List of companies based in Westport, Connecticut 2011-12-31 Delete Keep Made additional comment on 2012-01-02
22 Francesco Schettino 2012-01-21 Redirect Redirect
23 Republican Party vice presidential candidates, 2012 2012-05-08 Delete No consensus
24 Mitt Romney Cranbrook incident 2012-05-12 Delete Delete
25 Steve Obsitnik 2012-05-30 Redirect Redirect

Templates for discussion

# Template for discussion Date participated (UTC) My recommendation Consensus decision Notes
1 Template:The Penguins of Madagascar 2010-03-25 Delete Delete I was the nominator
2 Template:Bambi 2010-03-25 Delete Delete
3 Template:Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog 2011-02-09 Delete Delete I was the nominator
4 Template:A Bug's Life 2011-02-09 Delete Delete Also recommended an article edit
5 Template:FIBA Oceania associations 2011-02-09 Delete Delete
6 Template:Trang F.C. 2011-02-09 Delete Delete
7 Template:S.C.Ruffeyfan/Navbox 2011-02-09 Delete Delete
8 Template:Sint Maarten Island Council election, 2007 2011-02-17 Delete Delete Made additional comments on 2011-02-18 and 2011-02-20
9 Template:Simpsons episode 2011-02-17 Delete Delete
10 Template:Shreveport populationbox 2011-02-17 Delete Delete
11 Template:Appropriateness 2011-02-17 Delete Delete
12 Template:Jerusalem 2011-02-17 Comment in support of a name Merge
13 Middle East conflict 2011-02-17 Keep Keep
14 Template:Uw-sandbox 2011-02-17 Comment (with an implication that the template was not worthwhile) Delete
15 Template:Bernard Goldberg 2011-02-17 Delete Delete
16 Template:Section edit request 2011-02-20 Redirect Redirect
17 Template:Big Momma's House 2011-02-20 Delete Delete
18 Template:US federal budget 2011-02-21 Keep Keep
19 Template:Family Guy characters 2011-02-21 Support merge Merge
20 Template:Statist 2011-02-21 Delete Delete
21 Template:UK Upfront Club Chart 2011-02-24 Delete Delete
22 Template:Euro-myth-top 2011-02-24 Delete Speedy delete
23 Template:Current U.S. First Spouses 2011-02-26 Delete Delete I was the nominator
24 Template:Facebook 2011-02-26 Keep Keep/withdrawn
25 Template:Humor 2011-03-01 Keep Keep
26 Template:Whale 2011-03-04 Keep/rename Keep/no consensus to rename
27 Template:Family Matters 2011-03-06 Delete Delete
28 Template:Current MMOGCM 2011-03-06 Delete Delete
29 Template:User notes 2011-03-22 Delete Delete
30 Template:This user 2011-03-22 Keep Redirect
31 Template:Town/population 2011-03-22 Delete Delete
32 Template:American Social Conservatism 2011-03-22 Keep, with recommended improvement No consensus My suggestion was to have some sort of criteria for the names of people being listed as American social conservatives on the template, as opposed to just the apparent feelings of the template's creator
33 Template:Willow Smith 2011-03-23 Delete Delete I was the nominator
34 Template:SIM card sizes 2011-03-23 Delete Delete
35 Template:IDU 2011-03-29 Delete Delete
36 Template:User2a 2011-03-29 Redirect initially, but soon switched to delete Delete
37 Template:Uns-ip-van 2011-03-29 Delete Delete
38 Template:Being updated 2011-03-29 Delete Delete
39 Template:Mitcham 1994 2011-03-29 Delete Delete
40 Template:Climbing Terms 2011-03-30 Delete Delete
41 Template:Prehistoric Mammals intro 2011-04-09 Delete Delete
42 Template:Infobox SpongeBob SquarePants character 2011-04-14 Delete Delete
43 Template:User zionist 2011-04-25 Userfy Userfy As this discussion concerned a userbox, I mentioned that the discussion should have been listed at Wikipedia:Miscellany for deletion instead of at TfD. I commented further that userboxes being listed at MfD was standard Wikipedia practice on 2011-04-26. Though another editor further commented that indeed userboxes go to MfD, the nominator maintained that it was a WP:CREEP policy.
44 Template:Celebrity Clean Water Ambassadors of the Global Water Foundation 2011-04-28 Delete Delete
45 Template:True Jackson, VP 2011-06-06 Delete Delete
46 Template:Infobox model 2011-06-06 Keep Keep
47 Template:Poor English 2011-06-06 Keep Replace and delete
48 Template:Divbox 2011-08-27 Keep Keep
49 Template:Bridgeport Bluefish 2012-05-19 Delete Delete I was the nominator

Redirects for discussion

# Redirect for discussion Date participated (UTC) My recommendation Consensus decision Notes
1 Penguins of Madagascar: The Big Problem 2010-05-04 Delete Delete I was the nominator
2 Senior center 2010-05-04 Delete Delete
3 User:Beta cafe/Enter your new article name here 2011-02-25 Delete Keep
4 American Mexico 2011-02-25 Delete Delete
5 Eagles "Band" 2011-02-28 Delete (later withdrawn) Retargeted/withdrawn I nominated this for deletion, but in light of information provided by another editor in the discussion, I soon withdrew my nomination and retargeted the redirect instead
6 WikiProject Intelligence 2011-03-07 Delete Delete
7 (Note: The name of this redirect is just too long to display) 2011-03-30 Comment (with a 60/40 lean toward deleting) No consensus
8 Trespass (2010 film) 2011-03-30 Delete Delete
9 Air Asia Group Destination 2011-03-30 Keep Keep
10 Air Asia Group destinations 2011-03-30 Keep Keep
11 AirAsia destinations 2011-03-30 Keep Keep
12 آتْ 2011-03-30 Delete Delete Added an additional comment on 2011-03-31
13 Myammar 2011-03-30 Keep Keep
14 Santorum 2011-07-29 Oppose change Keep redirect as is

Miscellany for deletion

# Miscellany for deletion Date participated (UTC) My recommendation Consensus decision Notes
1 Talk:Jodi Rell/Archive index 2011-08-12 Delete Deleted per WP:CSD#G6 I was the nominator
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Sgt._R.K._Blue/XfD&oldid=498381902"