Beten: Difference between revisions

This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these messages) This article needs additional citations for verification. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. Find sources: "Beten" – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR (February 2007) (Learn how and when to remove this message) This article may need to be rewritten to comply with Wikipedia's quality standards. You can help. The talk page may contain suggestions. (May 2009) The neutrality of this article is disputed. Relevant discussion may be found on the talk page. Please do not remove this message until conditions to do so are met. (December 2018) (Learn how and when to remove this message) (Learn how and when to remove this message)

The three Beten (or Bethen, Beden) are a German group of three saints. They are adored in minor churches and chapels in South Tyrol (Italy), Upper Bavaria, Baden and the Rhineland. Although the tradition of the "Three Virgins" has existed since the late Middle Ages, it is observed only regionally and not included in the official lists of saints of the Catholic Church.

The name Beten first appeared in the works of Hans Christoph Schöll in the 1930s. It was derived from the common endings of the three women's names, of which some variants are:

• Einbet(h), Ambet(h), Embet(h), Ainbeth, Ainpeta, Einbede, Aubet
• Worbet(h), Borbet, Wolbeth, Warbede, Gwerbeth
• Wilbet(h), Willebede, Vilbeth, Fürbeth, Firpet, Cubet

References to St. Einbeth first appeared in Strasbourg in the second half of the 12th century; she became associated with Wilbeth and Worbeth in the second half of the 14th century. The three names's origins are unknown. In the era of 19th-century romanticism, speculation arose that the Three Virgins might be Christianized pagan Germanic, Celtic or Roman goddesses.

In 1936, local historian Hans Christoph Schöll of Heidelberg developed a theory that the three saints were derived from a Germanic or Indo-European Triple Goddess. Schöll admitted his treatise was not a scientific study based on linguistic evidence, but was formulated around phonetic similarities. He planned a second book with scientific evidence for his theory, but it was never published. Due to Schöll's lack of scientific methodology, his theory was rejected (H. Hepding 1936; E. Krieck 1936) by the scientific world. It has nevertheless spread in esoteric circles, almost exclusively in German-speaking countries.

In the 20th century, cultural anthropologists like M. Zender (1987) researched the history and distribution of the cult of the three saints in the Middle Ages and early modern times. Although many depictions of groups of three women (e.g. the Germanic and Celtic Matrones) have been found in Gallo-Roman culture, the names of the Beten did not appear in pre-medieval contexts, nor in Celtic literature of the British Isles.

In his work on the Beten, Schöll assumed that place names with syllables even slightly similar to the names of the Beten bore traces of their cult, e.g. Bet-, Bed-, Bad-, Batz-, Bott-, Boden-, Bettel-, Wetter-, Wetten-, Wetz-, Witz-, Pütz-, Bieders-, Patt- etc. Also the beginnings of the names are suspected to be preserved in town names with Am-, An-, Ein-, En-, Wil-, Wiel-, Wild-, Wol-, Wüll-, Bor-, Wor-, Bar-, War-, Werr-, Worr-, Kirr-, etc.

Consequently, a huge amount of applicable names have been found in Central Europe and Great Britain. It has been suggested that many European settlement names are derived from them; for example:

• In Germany: Bedburg, Bettendorf, Homburg-Beden
• In France: Besançon, Les Bets, Bessay and the mountain Bethoa
• In England, Bedford

Names such as these are supposed to define the range of a possible "Beten-cult".

Many of these names have other suggested derivations; for example, Besançon from *ves-, "mountain". (The ancient name of Besançon was actually Vesontio.) In the long run, associating place-names with Beten without some knowledge of linguistic methodology is highly speculative.

• Anton Bauer, Zur Verehrung der hl. drei Jungfrauen Ainbeth, Gwerbeth und Fürbeth im Bistum Freising. In: Bayerisches Jahrbuch für Volkskunde 1961, S.33-44
• Rolf Wilhelm Brednich, Volkserzählungen und Volksglaube von den Schicksalsfrauen., Suomalainen Tiedeakatemia, Helsinki 1964
• H. Hepding: Review of: Hans Christoph Schöll, Die drei Ewigen (1936), Hessische Blätter für Volkskunde 35, 1936, S.167-171
• E. Krieck: Review of: Hans Christoph Schöll, Die drei Ewigen (1936), Oberdeutsche Zeitschrift für Volkskunde 10, 1936, S.136 ff.
• E. Kost: Review of: Schöll, Hans Christoph, Die drei Ewigen, Württembergisch Franken 19, 1938, S. 190 f.
• Erni Kutter, Der Kult der drei Jungfrauen. Eine Kraftquelle weiblicher Spiritualität neu entdeckt, München 1997^{[unreliable source?]}
• Erni Kutter, Heilige Frauen in der evangelischen Kirche. Eine Einladung zur Spurensuche im Münster von Heilsbronn; in: Efi. Die evangelische Frauenzeitschrift für Bayern 2 (2001)^{[unreliable source?]}
• Hans Christoph Schöll, Die drei Ewigen. Eine Untersuchung über germanischen Bauernglauben. Jena 1936
• Matthias Zender, Die Verehrung von drei heiligen Frauen im christlichen Mitteleuropa und ihre Vorbereitungen in alten Vorstellungen. In: Matronen und verwandte Gottheiten. Rheinland-Verlag, Köln 1987 (Beihefte der Bonner Jahrbücher 44)

• Hodge, Winifred, Matrons and Disir:The Heathen Tribal Mothers. English language.
• The Bethen - The Bavarian Triple Goddess. English article in druidry.org.