Polyandry: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added

Inline

Revision as of 03:28, 12 May 2008

In social anthropology and sociobiology, polyandry (Greek: poly- many, andros- man) means forming a sexual union with more than one male.

The form of polyandry in which two (or more) brothers marry the same woman is known as fraternal polyandry, and it is believed by many anthropologists to be the most frequently encountered form.

Definition

In social anthropology, polyandry refers to a form of polygamous marriage. Polyandry is a specific form of polygamy in which one woman is married to two or more husbands simultaneously. Polygyny refers to polygamy in which one man has two or more wives.

Human polyandry

According to inscriptions describing the reforms of the Sumerian king Urukagina of Lagash (ca. 2300 BC), he is said to have abolished the former custom of polyandry in his country, on pain of the woman taking multiple husbands being stoned with rocks upon which her crime is written^[1].

Polyandry in human relationships occurs or has occurred in Tibet, the Canadian Arctic, Zanskar, Nepal, Bhutan, Ladakh, the Nymba, and Sri Lanka^{[citation needed]}, and is known to have been present in some pre-contact Polynesian societies ^[2], though probably only among higher caste women ^[3]. It is also encountered in some regions of Mongolia, among the Mosuo people in China, and in some Sub-Saharan African and American indigenous communities. Polyandry has been practiced in several cultures in India — in the Jaunsar region in Uttarakhand, among the, Nairs, Theeyas and Toda of South India, and the Nishi of Arunachal Pradesh^{[citation needed]}. The Guanches, the first known inhabitants of the Canary Islands, practiced polyandry until their disappearance.^{[citation needed]} In other societies, there are people who live in de facto polyandrous arrangements that are not recognized by the law . Non-fraternal polyandry is extremely rare and is marked by violence. There are no known indigenous communities that currently practice polyandry involving unrelated males.

In Religion

The Hebrew Bible prohibits polyandry. For a woman to have sexual relations when she is married to another (which would include a situation such as polyandry) would constitute adultery, with the consequences that it would have on her status, as well as of her children from that relationship.

Islam also bans polyandry. In Islam the verse from the Quran that is typically used for a proof in this matter is Surah Nisa’ Chapter 4 verses 22 to 24, which gives the list of women with whom one cannot marry and it is further mentioned in Surah Nisa’ Chapter 4 verse 24. Nikah Ijtimah, a pre-Islamic tradition of polyandry, was forbidden by Islam.

There is at least one reference to polyandry in the ancient Hindu epic, Mahabharata. Draupadi marries the five Pandava brothers. This ancient text remains largely neutral to the concept of polyandry, accepting this as her way of life.

Controversy

Polyandry is a controversial subject among anthropologists. For instance, Pennsylvania anthropologist Stephen Beckerman points out that at least 20 tribal societies accept that a child could, and ideally should, have more than one father, referring to it as "partible paternity". On the other hand, in Tibet, which is the best-documented cultural domain within which polyandry is practised, the certain polyandrists themselves testify that the marriage form is difficult to sustain. ^{[citation needed]}

Given the rates of infidelity and divorce in traditionally monogamous societies, and so the supposed failure rate of polyandry (and polygamy in general^{[citation needed]}), it can be argued that polyandry is not uniquely unworkable. In Tibet polyandry has been outlawed, so it is difficult to measure the incidence of polyandry in what may have been the world's most "polyandrous" society.

In other parts of the world, most traditional societies have been drastically altered or destroyed, so the incidence of polyandry in the past may not be accurately known. In India, among Tibetan refugee groups who fled the Chinese takeover of their country, polyandry is seldom encountered.^{[citation needed]}

Causes

Some forms of polyandry appear to be associated with (a) the perceived need to retain aristocratic titles or agricultural lands within kin groups, and/or (b) frequent male absence, for long periods, from the household. As to the former variety, consider that in Tibet where the practice is particularly popular among the priestly Skye class as well as poor small farmers who could ill afford to divide their small holdings. As to the latter variety, as some males return to the household, others leave for a long time, so that there is usually one husband present. Also, polyandry serves as a form of birth control- no matter how many partners a woman has, she can only have one pregnancy at a time (as opposed to polygyny- a husband with multiple wives might impregnate all of them, thus having more children.)

Fraternal polyandry

Fraternal polyandry (from the Latin frater - brother) is a form of polyandrous marriage in which two or more brothers share one wife or more. It is also termed adelphogamy, but this term also has other meanings.^{[citation needed]}

Fraternal polyandry is found especially in certain areas of Tibet and Nepal, where polyandry is accepted as a social practice.^[4]

Apart from the famous example of fraternal polyandry in Mahabharata, there are many more instances, both in Hindu history and folk-lore. In contemporary Hindu society, due to sexual discrimination leading to sharp loss of number of marriageable women, many social scientists have expressed a fear of critical compulsion of polyandry in the near future. The 2003 film Matrubhoomi : A Nation without Women, is about such a terrible culture-clash where besides five brothers who share a wife, the father too claims his husbandry, leading to murder and ultimately to a gang war, when the whole village makes such a claim.

Fraternal polyandry achieves a similar goal to what primogeniture did in 19th-century England. Primogeniture dictated that the eldest son inherited the family estate, while younger sons had to leave home and seek their own employment. Primogeniture maintained family estates intact over generations by permitting only one heir per generation. Fraternal polyandry also accomplishes this, but does so by keeping all the brothers together with just one wife so that there is only one set of heirs per generation.^{[citation needed]}

Though technically not true polyandry, there exists a similar custom mentioned in the Old Testament which is described as levirate marriage. This is explained in Deuteronomy 25:5. If a man's brother dies childless and leaves a widow, that man shall be obliged to take his brother's wife for the purpose of producing an heir to the deceased brother's inheritance.

Nonhuman animal polyandry

In the field of behavioural ecology polyandry is a type of breeding adaptation in which one female mates with many males. Another similar breeding system to this is polygyny in which one male mates with many females (e.g., lions, deer, some primates and many systems where there is an alpha male).

A common example of this can be found in the Field Cricket Gryllus bimaculatus of the invertebrate order Orthoptera (containing crickets, grasshoppers and groundhoppers). The unusual thing about polyandry in nature in general is that mating is costly: in other words, why mate with more than one male when you could be better spending your time foraging? Females in this species will mate with any male close to them, including siblings. Widely shown in frogs (Agile frogs, Rana dalmatina), polyandry was also documented in polecat (Mustela putorius) and other mustelids. Related to sexual conflict, Thierry Lodé^[5] found possible explanations for polyandry include mate competition and inbreeding avoidance.

It is easier to ensure reproductive success (i.e. it is more likely that the female will have offspring)
Females may be encouraging sperm competition between males post-copulation
multiple sperm lines may confer more variation in traits to female's offspring, this seems to be the case in the honey bee where bees from different sperm lines excel at different roles within a single hive, benefiting the health of the hive as a whole.
Females may receive food offerings from prospective mates inciting copulation
Because males can't be sure if they are or aren't their offspring and won't risk destroying their own DNA, mating with multiple males increases the survival of the female's offspring.

Polyandry also occurs in some primates such as marmosets ), mammal groups the marsupial genus Antechinus, around 1% of all bird species, such as jacanas, insects such as honeybees, and fish such as pipefish. In effect polyandry will reduce the effective population size of a given closed population.^{[citation needed]}

Polyandry in New World monkeys

Some New World monkeys, for example Goeldi's Marmoset, have been observed living in polyandrous groups. Although groups may contain more than one female, the dominant female suppresses ovulation in subordinates, causing her to be the only one capable of reproduction. A Goeldi's Marmoset female regularly births more than one offspring, and her eggs are separately fertilized by more than one male. Paternal investment is high among Goeldi's Marmosets, and males often carry infants on their backs even if they are not the father of the infant. It has been suggested that multiple male mates were related, and therefore cooperation in caring for each other's young is adaptive; however, researchers tagged and tracked Goeldi's Marmosets over time, and noticed that unrelated males migrated to new groups to cooperate with non relatives as well as with relatives to care for young. It has also been suggested that females select cooperative males, and that the multiple offspring of Goeldi's Marmosets require paternal care for survival.^{[citation needed]}

Current research suggests that polyandry is the dominant social structure in the Callitrichinae subfamily of New World monkeys.

Sociobiology of polyandry

The term has gained some currency in sociobiology, where it refers, analogously, to a mating system in which one female forms more or less permanent bonds to more than one male. It can take two different forms. In one, typified by the Northern Jacana and some other ground-living birds, the female takes on much the same role as the male in a polygynous species, holding a large territory within which several males build nests. Subsequently, the female lays eggs in all the nests, and plays little part in parental care. In the other form, typified by the Galápagos Hawk, a group of two or more males (which may or may not be related) and one female collectively care for a single nest. The latter situation more closely resembles typical human fraternal polyandry.^{[citation needed]}

These two forms reflect different resource situations: polyandry with shared parental care is more likely in very difficult environments, where the efforts of more than two parents are needed to give a reasonable chance of rearing young successfully.

Honeybees are said to be polyandrous because a queen typically mates with multiple males, even though mating is the only interaction that they have (the males die off, while the queen uses stored sperm for eggs she fertilizes).

Polyandry in primates and other mammals is usually correlated with reduced or reverse sexual dimorphism — females larger than males. When males of a species are much larger than females, polygyny is usually practiced. As size difference decreases, or the females are larger than males, a species is more likely to practice monogamy or polyandry. The great apes (gorillas, orangutans, and chimpanzees) are dismorphic and practice polygyny. Male and female gibbons (lesser apes) are similar in size and form monogamous pairs. Human males and females are less dismorphic in body size than other polygynous great apes.

Paternal investment is often high in polyandrous species.

References

Levine, Nancy, The dynamics of polyandry: Kinship, domesticity and population on the Tibetan border, Chicago: 1988, University of Chicago Press. ISBN 0226475697, ISBN 978-0226475691
Peter, Prince of Greece, A Study of Polyandry, The Hague, Mouton, 1963

^ The Powers p. 40 by Walter Wink, 1992
^ Goldman I, 1970 Ancient Polynesian Society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press
^ Thomas, N. 1987. “Complementarity and History: Misrecognizing Gender in the Pacific.” Oceania, 57(4):261-270
^ Levine, Nancy, The dynamics of polyandry: Kinship, domesticity and population on the Tibetan border, Chicago: 1988, University of Chicago Press.
^ T Lodé “la guerre des sexes chez les animaux” Eds O Jacob, Paris, 2006, ISBN 2-7381-1901-8

@@ Line 15: / Line 15: @@
 === In Religion ===
+The [[Hebrew Bible]] prohibits [[polyandry]]. For a woman to have sexual relations when she is married to another (which would include a situation such as polyandry) would constitute [[adultery]], with the consequences that it would have on her status, as well as of her children from that relationship.
-[[Islam]] and [[Judaism]] {{Fact|date=April 2008}} ban polyandry completely. In Islam the verse from the [[Quran]] that is typically used for a proof in this matter is Surah Nisa’ Chapter 4 verses 22 to 24, which gives the list of women with whom one cannot marry and it is further mentioned in Surah Nisa’ Chapter 4 verse 24. [[Nikah Ijtimah]], a pre-Islamic tradition of polyandry, was forbidden by Islam.
+[[Islam]] also bans polyandry. In Islam the verse from the [[Quran]] that is typically used for a proof in this matter is Surah Nisa’ Chapter 4 verses 22 to 24, which gives the list of women with whom one cannot marry and it is further mentioned in Surah Nisa’ Chapter 4 verse 24. [[Nikah Ijtimah]], a pre-Islamic tradition of polyandry, was forbidden by Islam.
 There is at least one reference to polyandry in the ancient [[Hindu]] epic, ''[[Mahabharata]]''. [[Draupadi]] marries the five [[Pandava]] brothers. This ancient text remains largely neutral to the concept of polyandry, accepting this as her way of life.