Wikipedia:New pages patrol/Backlog drives/November 2021/Re-reviews: Difference between revisions
Appearance
Content deleted Content added
Lineslarge (talk | contribs) →Lineslarge: Archie McEachern added |
→Sdrqaz: Addition of a clutch of re-reviews and pinging User:Joseywales1961 since I've taken issue with one of his reviews |
||
Line 89: | Line 89: | ||
=== [[User:Sdrqaz|Sdrqaz]] === |
=== [[User:Sdrqaz|Sdrqaz]] === |
||
# [[Wren Williams]] – [[User:Buidhe]] – |
# [[Wren Williams]] – [[User:Buidhe]] – Correctly marked as reviewed; had been tagged as being an orphan, stub, and having category issues by the creator. |
||
# [[Maria Savchenko]] – [[User:Mccapra]] – Correctly marked as reviewed, but no stub tag added |
# [[Maria Savchenko]] – [[User:Mccapra]] – Correctly marked as reviewed, but no stub tag added; orphan tag added by reviewer. |
||
# [[Federico Granja Ricalde]] – [[User:Joseywales1961]] – |
# [[Federico Granja Ricalde]] – [[User:Joseywales1961]] – Correctly marked as reviewed; categories and stub tag added by reviewer. |
||
# [[R. Narendra]] – [[User:Joseywales1961]] – |
# [[R. Narendra]] – [[User:Joseywales1961]] – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator. |
||
# [[T. Raghumurthy]] – [[User:Styyx]] – |
# [[T. Raghumurthy]] – [[User:Styyx]] – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator. |
||
# [[2020 Thomas Cup group stage]] – [[User:Joseywales1961]] – Correctly marked as reviewed. |
|||
# [[Christos Zanteroglou]] – [[User:TheWikiholic]] – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator. |
|||
# [[Tasos Vasiliou]] – [[User:TheWikiholic]] – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator. |
|||
# [[Nikos Simigdalas]] – [[User:TheWikiholic]] – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator. |
|||
# [[Thanasis Saravakos]] – [[User:TheWikiholic]] – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator. |
|||
# [[Giannis Komianidis]] – [[User:Styyx]] – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator. |
|||
# [[Giannis Fronimidis]] – [[User:Styyx]] – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator. |
|||
# [[Fotis Balopoulos]] – [[User:TheWikiholic]] – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator. |
|||
# [[Marios Orfanidis]] – [[User:DanCherek]] – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator. |
|||
# [[Drosos Kalotheou]] – [[User:DanCherek]] – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator. |
|||
# [[Panikos Iakovou]] – [[User:DanCherek]] – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator. |
|||
# [[Andros Antoniadis]] – [[User:Joseywales1961]] – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator. |
|||
# [[K. T. Kumaran]] – [[User:Joseywales1961]] – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by reviewer, which was replaced with a more specific tag by re-reviewer. |
|||
# [[Seong Ho-yeong]] – [[User:Joseywales1961]] – Correctly marked as reviewed; {{tl|one source}} tag added by reviewer. Hatnote to a similarly-named Korean footballer added by re-reviewer. |
|||
# [[Lee Tae-min (footballer, born 2003)]] – [[User:Joseywales1961]] – Incorrectly marked as reviewed; subject is the same as [[Lee Tae-min (footballer)]]. Converted into a redirect by re-reviewer and information merged. |
|||
=== [[User:Styyx|Styyx]] === |
=== [[User:Styyx|Styyx]] === |
Revision as of 00:59, 7 November 2021
To re-review articles, list your name below followed by a numbered list of the articles you have re-reviewed. To find articles to re-review, go to Wikipedia:Database reports/Top new article reviewers, pick any editor, and visit the log to find articles that they have reviewed since the start of the drive. Make sure to note the original reviewer and whether the original review was correct. If you found problems with the original review, please discuss it with the original reviewer on the backlog drive talk page.
- Lorem ipsum — User:Nobody — I found it was 110% copyvio with earwig and nominated it for speedy deletion.
I am only re-reviewing articles originally reviewed by users signed up to the backlog drive
- Hi8 — User:Polyamorph — I found it was correctly tagged for refimprove
- Akasa Air — User:WaddlesJP13 — I found it was correctly tagged as a stub
- Amshi de Silva — User:Htanaungg — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Paul May (footballer) — User:DanCherek — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Dubnevich Yaroslav Vasilyevich — User:Mccapra — I found it was correctly tagged for cleanup (possibly needs a page move when a Ukrainian speaker comes along)
- Lobostemon echioides — User:Usedtobecool — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Amatsia Levkovich — User:Styyx — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- 1929 Melbourne Cup — User:Shellwood — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Stojan Titelbah — User:ThadeusOfNazereth — I found it was correctly tagged for unclear reference style
- Giovanni Molari — User:Buidhe — I found it was correctly tagged for refimprove
- Ermanno Fumagalli — User:Hughesdarren — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- 1969 Banja Luka earthquake — User:Hatchens — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Viorel Cataramă — User:Less Unless — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Sweet California — User:Nightenbelle — I found it was correctly tagged for unreliable sources and NPOV
- Don't Turn Your Back — User:Bada Kaji — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Eargasm — User:Scope creep — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Sam Acheampong — User:Elli — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Uri Weinberg — User:Styyx — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- 64th Evening Standard Theatre Awards — User:Ulubatli Hasan — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Fragaria emeiensis — User:Tol — I added a stub mark, otherwise no issues
- ISKCON Temple, Salem — User:Simon Peter Hughes — I found it was correctly tagged as a stub and refimprove
- Robert Gaffner — User:Novem Linguae — Non-notable politician, I found it was correctly nominated for AfD, copyvio removed and revdel requested by reviewer
- Gedion Timotheos — User:Curbon7 — I found it was correctly tagged as a stub, BLP sources and copy edit
- Ernesto Velasco — User:Citing — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Saadiah (actress) — User:Robertsky — I found it was correctly tagged for refimprove
- Cryotome — User:Htanaungg — I added a stub tag, otherwise ok
- Chris Kiptoo — User:Htanaungg — The decision to mark as patrolled was right since the subject is the head of a national agency. One thing that I would criticise is that no rating was given on the talk page and no stub tag was added.
- Eku Wand — User:Scope creep — Correctly marked as reviewed.
I am going to make an effort to only re-review articles from this backlog drive
- Good place 4 — User:Arthistorian1977 — No issues, just a redirect. Correctly marked as reviewed.
- Reality competition show - User:Arthistorian1977 — No issues, another redirect. Correctly marked as reviewed.
- Return of the Prodigal Son (Law & Order: Special Victims Unit episode) - User:Arthistorian1977 — I added banners on the talk page. Correctly marked as reviewed.
- Zespri - User:DannyS712 bot III - Added short description, rm redlink. Correctly marked as reviewed. (should I be reviewing a bot's patrolling?)
- International Jump Rope Union - User:Scope creep - Added banners. Correctly marked as reviewed.
- Archie McEachern — User:Less Unless — I found it was correctly marked as reviewed. No issues.
- Chronology of Provisional Irish Republican Army actions (1990–1991) — User:Elli — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Hugo Scouts — User:Styyx — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Building of Council of Labor and Defense — User:Mccapra — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- University of Strathclyde Sports Union — User:Usedtobecool — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- St Mary's Church, Carrigaline — User:Usedtobecool — No issues, correctly marked reviewed; removed {{orphan}} since it has already been deorphaned
- Krasny Kamysh — User:Usedtobecool — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- St Luke's Church, Summerhill North — User:Usedtobecool — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Zavidny, Kursk Oblast — User:Usedtobecool — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- 2021–22 Lamar Lady Cardinals basketball team — User:Bada Kaji — Found correctly tagged for linkrot; fixed the issue and removed the tag
- Super Crooks — User:Govvy — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Rise (2022 film) — User:Govvy — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Elisabeth Freundlich — User:Govvy — Correctly tagged stub and expand translation
- Sergiu Mișcoiu — User:Govvy — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- List of historical monuments in Qatar — User:Ymblanter — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Prelestny — User:Ymblanter — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Miedzeszyn — User:Ymblanter — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Zona Franca (Barcelona Metro) — User:Ymblanter — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Ministry of Agriculture and Livestock (Guinea) — User:Ymblanter — No issues, correctly marked reviewed; removed orphan tag
- Entypus fulvicornis — User:Tol — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Dipogon sayi — User:Tol — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Auplopus architectus — User:Tol — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Panacanthus — User:Tol — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Agathidium mandibulare — User:Tol — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- John B. Scott (Texas politician) — User:DanCherek — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Coloradisuchus — User:Shellwood — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Epauletted parakeets — User:Hughesdarren — No issues, correctly marked reviewed
- Wren Williams – User:Buidhe – Correctly marked as reviewed; had been tagged as being an orphan, stub, and having category issues by the creator.
- Maria Savchenko – User:Mccapra – Correctly marked as reviewed, but no stub tag added; orphan tag added by reviewer.
- Federico Granja Ricalde – User:Joseywales1961 – Correctly marked as reviewed; categories and stub tag added by reviewer.
- R. Narendra – User:Joseywales1961 – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator.
- T. Raghumurthy – User:Styyx – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator.
- 2020 Thomas Cup group stage – User:Joseywales1961 – Correctly marked as reviewed.
- Christos Zanteroglou – User:TheWikiholic – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator.
- Tasos Vasiliou – User:TheWikiholic – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator.
- Nikos Simigdalas – User:TheWikiholic – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator.
- Thanasis Saravakos – User:TheWikiholic – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator.
- Giannis Komianidis – User:Styyx – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator.
- Giannis Fronimidis – User:Styyx – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator.
- Fotis Balopoulos – User:TheWikiholic – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator.
- Marios Orfanidis – User:DanCherek – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator.
- Drosos Kalotheou – User:DanCherek – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator.
- Panikos Iakovou – User:DanCherek – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator.
- Andros Antoniadis – User:Joseywales1961 – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by creator.
- K. T. Kumaran – User:Joseywales1961 – Correctly marked as reviewed; stub tag added by reviewer, which was replaced with a more specific tag by re-reviewer.
- Seong Ho-yeong – User:Joseywales1961 – Correctly marked as reviewed; {{one source}} tag added by reviewer. Hatnote to a similarly-named Korean footballer added by re-reviewer.
- Lee Tae-min (footballer, born 2003) – User:Joseywales1961 – Incorrectly marked as reviewed; subject is the same as Lee Tae-min (footballer). Converted into a redirect by re-reviewer and information merged.
- 2021 U23 World Wrestling Championships – Men's freestyle 79 kg – User:Joseywales1961 – Correctly tagged for bare references, replaced it with a full citation
- Anand Pillay — User:Htanaungg — Moved "External links" section, added short description, changed resume tag for sections tag, sentance case for headers. Correctly marked as reviewed.
- Ricard Artero — User:Joseywales1961 — No issues. Correctly marked as reviewed.
- Efi Achtsioglou — User:Mccapra — Added short desc and project class ratings. Correctly marked as reviewed.