John 20:12

John 20:12
← 20:11 20:13 →
James Tissot's The Angel Seated on the Stone of the Tomb.
Book	Gospel of John
Christian Bible part	New Testament

John 20:12 is the twelfth verse of the twentieth chapter of the Gospel of John in the New Testament of the Christian Bible. Mary Magdalene is peering into the empty tomb of Jesus and sees two angels.

Content

In the King James Version of the Bible the text reads:

And seeth two angels in white

sitting, the one at the head,

and the other at the feet, where

the body of Jesus had lain.

The English Standard Version translates the passage as:

And she saw two angels in white,

sitting where the body of Jesus had lain,

one at the head and one at the feet.

For a collection of other versions see BibleHub John 20:12

Analysis

There is some confusion between this account and that of the other gospels. In Matthew 28 only a single angel is mentioned. Mark 16 refers to a young man, presumably an angel, sitting on the right side. In Luke two men, identified as angels in Luke 24:23, appear standing next to the women. Those who believe in the inerrancy of the Bible argue that these multiple accounts are explained by Mary making multiple trips to the tomb.

This is the only time in the Gospel of John that angels appear. Rationalist critics believe that there were never any angels and that they were a later embellishment to the tale. Schnackenburg is one who believes the angels were a later addition to the narrative. He argues they were added to reinforce the evidence that the body of Jesus was gone. By indicating that the angels were sitting where the head and feet of Jesus were it shows that a full examination of the spot had been conducted. This also explains why the angels are so quickly forgotten later in the chapter.^[1]

Some have linked the two angels guarding the tomb with the pair that were said to guard the Ark of the Covenant. Wetstein has advanced a thesis linking the pair of angels to the pair of criminals who were crucified alongside Jesus.

The angels appear in the standard garb of Biblical angels, who are always portrayed as either wearing white or radiant clothing. The exact form of the angels is uncertain. The text does not make clear if they were in the form of normal men, who Mary did perhaps not recognize as angels, or if they were the radiant beings Biblical angels are often described as.

The position of the angels says something about the tomb. That they are sitting on something seems to imply that Jesus' body was on a raised shelf or ledge. This is consistent with the rest of the Gospel. However, early pilgrims to Jesus' tomb report that his body was placed in a trough in the tomb. Bruce argues that the grave may very well have been a trough as "angels would not require the same material support as beings of flesh and blood."^[2] Some scholars believe that the clear distinction between the head and foot indicates that Jesus' tomb was one that had a built in headrest. Others believe the writer is just referring to the direction in which Jesus had been placed.

The other question is why the angels failed to appear to the disciples when they examined the tomb. Westcott explains this by arguing that "such manifestations necessarily follow the laws of a spiritual economy."^[3]

References

Bibliography

• Brown, Raymond E. "The Gospel According to John: XIII-XI" The Anchor Bible Series Volume 29A New York: Doubleday & Company, 1970.
• John Calvin's commentary on John 20:10-15
• Jesus Appears to His Disciples